SARS’s draft crypto tax guide: has decentralised finance been left in the 'too difficult' box?

While the SARS Draft Guide to the Taxation of Crypto Assets provides guidance on how existing South African income tax principles may apply to crypto assets, it contains a notable omission. Belinda Sussman, Dale Cridlan, and Shei Silver of Deneys explore the issue of decentralised finance

OPINION

In July 2026, the South African Revenue Service’s (SARS) issued a Draft Guide to the Taxation of Crypto Assets.

The draft provides guidance on how existing South African income tax principles may apply to crypto assets. It considers the sale and exchange of crypto assets, the use of crypto to pay for goods and services, crypto arbitrage, mining, staking, airdrops and hard forks. 

There is one notable omission, namely the tax treatment of decentralised finance.

What about decentralised finance?

The draft guide includes one paragraph on decentralised finance, or DeFi. It describes DeFi as an alternative financial system using blockchain and smart contracts to provide financial services, ranging from lending and borrowing to complex derivative transactions. The guide does not deal with DeFi arrangements, other than to say that the particular arrangement must be understood and that normal income tax and capital gains tax principles must be applied. 

That caution is understandable as DeFi encompasses a wide variety of arrangements and is developing rapidly. A simple tax rule applicable to every transaction would therefore be neither realistic nor necessarily desirable. But the practically complete exclusion of DeFi from a guide specifically intended to assist taxpayers with the taxation of crypto assets arguably leaves a significant gap.

Why DeFi matters

DeFi essentially seeks to provide financial services through blockchain-based technology and decentralised protocols. By removing traditional intermediaries, DeFi aims to provide a more accessible and efficient financial system with reduced reliance on centralised control.

Crypto assets are the primary assets utilised within DeFi systems. These include native crypto assets of the blockchains on which DeFi protocols operate, such as Ether, and tokens issued on those blockchains including stablecoins and wrapped versions of other crypto assets such as Bitcoin.

Tokens are utilised as the means of exchange and as the assets through which individuals trade, lend or otherwise participate in the activities of the DeFi protocol.

DeFi is not merely a theoretical development at the fringes of the crypto world. The Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) published a market study research paper in February 2025 on Decentralised Finance in South Africa, examining the DeFi ecosystem, its use cases, benefits and risks and the views of the South African market. The FSCA paper states that “Although DeFi market size is still very small compared to the traditional financial sector, it is imperative for the FSCA to continuously monitor the sector for any risks that might be detrimental to consumers’ welfare.”

If another South African financial regulator considers DeFi sufficiently significant to make this statement in writing, and to warrant a dedicated market study, its exclusion from practical consideration in SARS's crypto tax guide seems particularly noticeable.

The difficulty is precisely why guidance is needed

The problem with saying that "normal tax principles" should simply be applied is that identifying how those principles apply can be particularly difficult in a DeFi environment.

Consider a relatively common arrangement in which a taxpayer supplies crypto assets to a liquidity pool, receives a token representing the taxpayer's participation in that pool, earns additional tokens or fees and later withdraws assets from the pool.

A number of tax questions immediately arise.

Has depositing the original crypto asset into the liquidity pool of the protocol constituted a disposal for capital gains tax or income tax purposes? When does any yield or reward "accrue" to the taxpayer? How should it be valued? What is the base cost of a token generated through the arrangement? And what happens when the taxpayer ultimately exits the liquidity pool?

The answer will likely depend upon the legal rights and obligations created by the particular smart contract and the precise mechanics of the relevant protocol. Indeed, SARS itself repeatedly recognises in its draft guide that the detailed characteristics of crypto assets and transactions can fundamentally affect their tax consequences. 

That is a perfectly legitimate reason not to prescribe one answer for every DeFi arrangement. It is, however, the very reason why taxpayers would benefit from guidance. This is all the more important because the draft guide also states that, “as a rule of thumb, there is usually a tax event associated with the application of crypto assets”. When applied mechanically to a liquidity pool, that rule of thumb could give rise to a tax event on each deposit into and withdrawal from the pool, even when the taxpayer has not, in economic terms disposed of anything. 

South Africa is not alone in confronting the problem

The difficulty of applying traditional tax concepts to DeFi is not uniquely South African.

The United Kingdom's HM Revenue & Customs has specifically consulted on the taxation of DeFi involving cryptoasset lending and liquidity pools. Its work recognised that the growing use of smart contracts has increased both the number and complexity of transactions undertaken by individuals. It also consulted on whether the tax treatment of certain arrangements should be brought more closely into line with their economic substance. 

According to HMRC's published response, stakeholders unanimously supported HMRC examining the issue, calling for rules that were easier to comply with, reflected the economic reality of transactions and were sufficiently flexible to accommodate new arrangements. 

New Zealand’s Inland Revenue has gone further. On 29 January 2026, its Tax Counsel Office released a discussion document, issue paper IRRUIP18, setting out the Commissioner’s initial views on the income tax consequences of common DeFi transactions such as wrapping, bridging, lending, borrowing and staking. The paper does not provide guidance on particular protocols, but applies general principles to general types of transactions, illustrated by worked examples.

Notably, Inland Revenue takes a legal form rather than economic substance approach. In its view, a crypto asset is disposed of when it is transferred out of the holder’s wallet into a pool, vault or smart contract that the holder does not control, so that even a “temporary” transfer into a liquidity pool with a right to receive equivalent assets back is a disposal. By contrast, there is no disposal where crypto assets are merely locked in the holder’s own wallet or placed in an individual vault or smart contract, not pooled with other users’ assets, where the holder retains the private key. Inland Revenue characterises DeFi “lending” and “borrowing” as more comparable to sale and repurchase arrangements, and treats rewards as generally taxable when the holder can deal with them.

One may or may not agree with that approach, which may result in multiple taxable events in quick succession. The point, however, is that it gives taxpayers a clear starting position. It demonstrates that a revenue authority can provide meaningful DeFi guidance without addressing every protocol, while inviting feedback on whether its understanding of how DeFi transactions operate is correct.

DeFi is receiving international attention

The OECD has recognised that decentralised crypto services raise particular questions under its Crypto-Asset Reporting Framework and confirmed that further guidance on decentralised services is being developed. While this work concerns tax reporting rather than the underlying tax treatment of DeFi transactions, it nevertheless illustrates that DeFi has developed to the point where tax authorities need to consider it specifically.

A missed opportunity, but one that can still be addressed

Simply stating in the draft Guide that normal income tax and CGT principles apply to DeFi leaves taxpayers with little practical assistance. The real difficulty is determining how those principles apply to transactions that may have no obvious equivalent in traditional finance.

The period for public comment closed on 31 August 2026, but until the guide is finalised there is still an opportunity to fill the gap. SARS need not attempt to address every DeFi protocol or product. Guidance on common arrangements, such as crypto lending, borrowing, staking and liquidity pools, supported by practical examples along the lines of those in New Zealand’s issues paper, would go a long way towards providing taxpayers with greater certainty.

DeFi may be complex, but that complexity strengthens the case for guidance rather than diminishing it.

Belinda Sussman is a consultant and Chartered Accountant in the Deneys tax team in Johannesburg. Dale Cridlan is a registered tax practitioner and Head of the Tax team at Deneys. Shei Silver is a Candidate Attorney in the Johannesburg office.